top of page

Israel Needs a Renewed Liberal Vision. And It Needs to Find Its Voice.

5 days ago
5 min read

(an op-ed by Rotem Oreg-Kalisky, founder and director of LIBRAEL; the views are his own)


At Crooked Con 2026, I attended a panel discussing the United States and its approach to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. Aside from being probably the most "pro-Israel" voice in a room of a thousand people, I left with an uncomfortable realization: the liberal Zionist voice in the room had almost nothing compelling to say.


The Israel-Palestine panel on Crooked Con.
The Israel-Palestine Crooked Con Panel. One side was trying to defend the past with ideas and solutions from the past. The other was making an argument about the future.

While the liberal Zionist speaker, a senior member of one of the largest progressive pro-Israel groups in America, recycled familiar clichés and historical anecdotes, repeatedly returning to policy solutions like the two-state solution, the pro-Palestinian voice - a former State Department official who resigned from the Biden administration due to disagreements over Gaza - was passionate, morally grounded, and relevant to the audience and its moral compass. One side was trying to defend the past with ideas and solutions from the past. The other was making an argument - and quite a compelling one, I must say - about the future.


Our role at LIBRAEL is to articulate this vision, including through pieces like this one, in an inspiring, compelling, positive, ambitious, even "sexy" way.

And that, I believe, captures a much bigger problem facing liberal Zionism today. For too long, those of us who believe in both Israel and liberal values have defined ourselves by what we oppose: propaganda, antisemitism, double standards, and the delegitimization of Israel's very existence from the left, and racism, nationalism, and religious coercion from the right.


We were basically saying, "I support Israel, but I don't hate the Palestinians." This is not an invalid position in a world where senior government members talk about expelling two million Gazans, but it is far from sufficient. Liberal Zionists delved into the details and nuances of Israel's security challenges, reminded people of its history and past failed attempts, and pointed to Israel's democratic achievements as proof that "we're the good guys." All of this matters, but it does not persuade anyone who is not already convinced.


We cannot have a vision about Israel's future if we keep going to the past.


So what should a renewed liberal vision for Israel look like?


First, it must be unapologetically Zionist. Israel is the national home of the Jewish people, and its existence is not incompatible with liberal values. Instead, it is grounded in the self-evident truth that all people are created equal, meaning that Jews are entitled to the same rights as anyone else, including self-determination.


Liberal Zionism must stop recycling clichés, from "the only democracy in the Middle East" to "we must go back to the path of Rabin."

But Zionism should be about more than having a state. It should be about building a country worthy of the ideals that inspired its creation: a Chevrat Mofet, an ideal society that embraces opportunity, equality, and dignity for all.


Second, it must put democracy at its center. Not merely elections, but the institutions and principles that make democracy meaningful: an independent judiciary, separation of powers, minority rights, equality before the law, freedom of speech and expression, and a genuine commitment to pluralism. None of these are concessions made to "prove we're a democracy." They are essential to Israel's success as an extremely diverse society living in a tough neighborhood.


Hamas breaching the Gaza border.
Hamas breaching the border on October 7. We should never accept the presence of militias like Hamas and Hezbollah on our borders, and we should take out terror cells before they strike, while protecting the safety and rights of ordinary Palestinian civilians.

Third, it must offer a moral vision for the relationship between Israelis and Palestinians. We should be uncompromising about Israel's security while recognizing Palestinian dignity, rights, and aspirations. We should never accept the presence of militias like Hamas and Hezbollah on our borders, and we should take out terror cells before they strike, while opposing violence and injustice against Palestinians, particularly nationalist violence in the West Bank, as well as doing everything possible to improve the lives of Palestinian civilians, even during a diplomatic stalemate.


We must believe in a Jewish homeland without believing that Jewish sovereignty requires Palestinian oppression. Liberal Zionism is not about pretending the tension between security and individual rights does not exist, because it does. It is about remaining committed to our values even when they are tested.


Liberal Zionism should embrace Arab Israelis as equal partners in building an ideal society, remaining true to the vision of our founding fathers. It should be a safe home for the non-Jews who immigrated to Israel, whether fleeing war or seeking a better life, and allow them to become part of the Israeli story, as a nation and a people of immigrants.

Fourth, it must embrace the diversity of Israeli society. A liberal Israel should make room for religious and secular Jews from all denominations of Judaism. It should embrace Arab Israelis as equal partners in building an ideal society, remaining true to the vision of our founding fathers. It should protect the rights of LGBTQ+ people, as Jews know all too well what it is like to be discriminated against for who you are. It should be a safe home for the non-Jews who immigrated to Israel, whether fleeing war or seeking a better life, and allow them to become part of the Israeli story, as a nation and a people of immigrants. It should recognize that our strength lies not in forcing everyone into one national mold, but in building a shared society in which different identities thrive.


Pro-Ukraine protest in Tel Aviv
A pro-Ukraine protest in Tel Aviv. Israel must have a vision of its place in the world, standing alongside other democracies under threat from Ukraine to Taiwan.

Finally, we must articulate a vision of Israel's place in the world: a confident, secure, democratic country that contributes to human progress, seeks regional cooperation and integration, and stands alongside other democracies under threat from Ukraine to Taiwan. This requires understanding that Israel's global standing depends not only on military, economic, or technological power, but also on its moral character.


All of this means understanding that national security and liberal values are not mutually exclusive, but rather the two legs on which our future stands.


The next generation of liberal Zionists must stop recycling clichés, from "the only democracy in the Middle East" to "we must go back to the path of Rabin." Liberal Zionists must also move beyond an unconditional commitment to the two-state solution and keep an open mind to other ideas as well - as long as they fulfill our vision of Israel as a secure, democratic nation-state for the Jewish people, and of Palestinians living in freedom, dignity, and opportunity. We at LIBRAEL are not focusing on solutions, but on a vision that any solution, two-state or otherwise, should adhere to.


Our role at LIBRAEL is to articulate this vision, including through pieces like this one, in an inspiring, compelling, positive, ambitious, even "sexy" way. What liberal Zionists cannot do is expect Israel skeptics to embrace a movement whose main argument is explaining why Israel is not as bad as its critics claim.


If you liked our work, you may share our vision and values. You can help us live up to the urgent task we’ve taken upon ourselves by donating to LIBRAEL here. For tax-deductible donations in the United States, click here.

Comments


bottom of page